Daycare Center vs. In-Home - What Was Your Deciding Factor?

Curious to get some other perspectives on this. I’m in planning mode for childcare for my boys (3 and 2) for the next year and I’m stuck.

I’ve made a spreadsheet comparing our top two options: a traditional daycare center and a licensed in-home daycare. On paper, the costs are almost identical once I factor in everything (center has more closure days, in-home has a slightly higher weekly rate but fewer kids so maybe less sickness?).

Pros for the center are the structured curriculum and more kids for socialization. Pros for hte in-home are the smaller group size and a calmer environment. I feel like I have a solid list of pros and cons for both, but I’m in total analysis paralysis because neither is a clear winner financially or logistically.

For those who’ve made a similar choice, what was the one thing that tipped the scales for you? Was it a gut feeling? A specific policy? I’m trying to figure out what intangible factor I might be missing.